ACTA in the NewsTenure
Has tenure outlived its usefulness?
It is heresy inside the academy to say such a thing, but absent some serious reforms, tenure deserves to go the way of the spinning wheel and the
When it comes to budget cuts to higher education, it’s the ones that are unseen that may hurt the most.
As colleges and universities received their allotment of state funding for the current fiscal year this week, LSU system schools, like LSU-Shreveport, were instructed to find a way to cut 23 percent out of the 2011-12 fiscal budget as federal stimulus money ends.
But the more shocking news came when system President John Lombardi, visited LSUS recently.
“LSU is likely to declare exigency,” said Paul Sisson, LSUS provost.
Exigency is similar to bankruptcy in that the schools could restructure in a way that would help it survive economically. Certain rules are suspended and among them is the academic tradition of tenure. Tenure ensures academic freedom and offers some financial stability for professors. For professors, tenure is not only a goal but a reward for years of dedication to research and teaching. Not every professor earns tenure.
“It’s not the last thing you strive for but one of the big things you strive for,” he said. “You are recognized by your peers that you’re a good teacher, a good scholar and a good performer. That you can contribute to the working knowledge of the world.”
If the system files exigency on behalf of its schools, a tenured professor could be on the same financial chopping block as an adjunct professor. The security they once enjoyed would be diminished.
“Tenure matters (still) but it doesn’t give you the same level of job security,” he said.
In the past two years, LSUS has eliminated vacant positions, scaled back from four colleges to two, and has offered staff and faculty early retirement bonuses. Faculty and staff have taken on increased workloads. But with another cut looming on the horizon, it’s time to go deeper.
“Primary focus has been to protect students and protect degree programs,” he said. “As the crisis continues, it becomes less and less possible to protect the student. Everyone feels it; the community will feel it in any services we provide.”
While the suspension of tenure protection could help the bottom line, it could hurt morale. Ada Meloy, general counsel for the American Council on Education, said the unusual circumstances can make faculty uneasy.
Anne D. Neal, president of American Council of Trustees and Alumni, said despite the gloom and doom, there is a silver lining.
“It really allows institutions to focus on mission and eliminate fat that has accumulated during the feast years,” she said. “It really is the time to think outside of the box and restructure in a way that is beneficial for students.”
Should the system file exigency, LSUS would host campuswide meetings for restructuring input. Everyone will participate in those discussions, Sisson said.
“I’m proud at how we managed (the cuts),” he said. “We will get through it, but there will be pain. We’re still doing amazing things. Everyone needs to know that and contact their legislator and tell them ‘this is important to us.’ It would be a dismal and gray world without universities.”
It is heresy inside the academy to say such a thing, but absent some serious reforms, tenure deserves to go the way of the spinning wheel and the
ACTA's Emily Koons Jae and Bryan Paul recently sat down with Jenna Robinson, president of the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal, a nonprofit institute dedicated to improving higher education in North Carolina and the nation, to discuss the successes and shortcomings of higher ed reform in North Carolina.
Last week, the North Dakota House of Representatives passed HB 1446, creating a pilot program which would provide for post-tenure review of faculty members at two universities. The bill will now head to the Senate. The American Council of Trustees and Alumni (ACTA) has long held that tenure reform, if done well, will play a […]
Launched in 1995, we are the only organization that works with alumni, donors, trustees, and education leaders across the United States to support liberal arts education, uphold high academic standards, safeguard the free exchange of ideas on campus, and ensure that the next generation receives an intellectually rich, high-quality college education at an affordable price.
Discover MoreSign up to receive updates on the most pressing issues facing our college campuses.