ACTA in the News | Accreditation

Watchdog demands probe into Harvard that could put hundreds of millions of fed funding in jeopardy

NEW YORK POST   |  January 13, 2024 by Isabel Vincent

A watchdog group is demanding an accreditation institution probe Harvard University over its handling of plagiarism allegations against its former president Claudine Gay — a move that could determine if the Ivy League school continues to receive hundreds of millions in federal funding, The Post has learned.

The American Council of Trustees and Alumni, a Washington, DC-based non-profit, sent a formal complaint this week to the New England Commission of Higher Education, a group that has been accrediting universities for the Department of Education since its founding in 1885.

Harvard’s compliance with NECHE’s standards is
necessary for continued eligibility to receive funding under federal student loan programs, according to the complaint.

The 12-page complaint alleges that the Harvard Corporation, the school’s governing body, “appears to have willfully and persistently operated outside of Harvard’s established procedures” in the case of Gay, who resigned as the college’s president amid her disastrous testimony before Congress on antisemitism and claims of plagiarism earlier this month.

Harvard’s policy on reporting academic misconduct demands that any allegations are reported to school authorities right away, and “strictly forbids retaliation against complainants,” according to the complaint.

The Post was the first to approach Harvard last year about Gay’s alleged plagiarism.

A lawyer acting for the school said that the allegations were “demonstrably false” weeks before the governing board investigated Gay.

The attorney threatened The Post with a lawsuit.

ACTA says that the Harvard Corporation conducted an “irregular” and “opaque” investigation into its former president which veered from its own internal rules on reporting research misconduct and the standards set by NECHE.

“The Harvard Corporation and the former president seem to have established as a matter of public precedent that they can arbitrarily overrule and circumvent the established, faculty-approved policies and procedures governing allegations of research misconduct,” the complaint says. “Harvard appears to have shown to the world that its governing board can improvise and change investigative procedures, even from week to week.”

ACTA said a copy of its complaint has been sent to the House Committee on Education and the Workforce as well as Penny Pritzker, the most senior member of the Harvard Corporation.

A Harvard spokesman did not return a request for comment.

This article appeared on New York Post online January 13, 2024


Launched in 1995, we are the only organization that works with alumni, donors, trustees, and education leaders across the United States to support liberal arts education, uphold high academic standards, safeguard the free exchange of ideas on campus, and ensure that the next generation receives an intellectually rich, high-quality college education at an affordable price.

Discover More